A dino rib dripping with juice

Hungry for More?

4 Comments

  1. “though a little garlic wouldn’t hurt anyone.” Ummm….

    While I like learning from this blog, and there are a lot of good ideas, I have to speak back against this reason why I can’t use more of them. My daughter is Epi-pen level allergic to both onion and garlic – were I to serve this to her, she would find it ‘spicy’ as her mouth and throat would prickle and start swelling to the point that she would not be able to breathe, and the Epi-pen’s adrenaline would leave her sleep off for several days while she recovered.

    I would like to find another barbecue rub other than salt-and-pepper or Penzey’s _Barbecue of the Americas_ that is onion and garlic free. This doesn’t help.

    1. Oh my! Of course when we say things like ” a little extra butter won’t hurt,” we don’t mean that everyone can have it…those with heart conditions or milk allergies of course Shouldn’t follow a comment like that. BUT. An Allium allergy like that is a tough thing to deal with in BBQ, as almost all BBQ rub shave some garlic or onion. It is well within Texas-style parameters to use a BBQ rub composed ONLY of salt and pepper. Combine 1 Cup 40-mesh black pepper and 1 Cup kosher salt, and use that as a rub. I LOVE BBQ prepared this way, and I hope you (and your daughter) will too! If you follow any recipe from a respectable BBQ cook, just omitting the alliums, you should end up with something pretty tasty.

  2. 5 stars
    I’ve tried this several times with chuck roast but the meat, while tasty, seemed to be too dry, probably because it was heated too long trying to reach 200F. I wrapped the meat at 150F after it became stalled. I also removed the wrap before resting but did not rest for hours.

    Q1 … When should the wrap be applied? It would seem that the slope of the temperature-time curve (drops to < 10F/hr ? ) might be a good parameter to monitor ,,,

    Q2 … Reaching 200F even when wrapped seemed to take too long. Is there an alternate measure of doneness, again looking for a temperature-time slope change?

    Q3 … When should the wrap be removed? At the beginning or completion of the rest period?

    1. Before we get to the questions, I think removing the wrap before resting is a mistake. The wrap prevents evaporative cooling, allowing the meat to continue the collagen melt. By removing the wrap, you let the meat cool precipitously, spoiling part of what the wrap is supposed to accomplish. Though some pitmasters do “burb” the meat, opening the wrap to let out an initial burst of steam and heat, then immediately closing the wrap again. Just something to chew on, as it were. OK, on to the questions.

      1— A change like that in the slope curve is a great time to wrap, provided your bark has set. You might wait ’til it has dropped as lo as 3–5°F if the bark isn’t scratch-proof yet. But you’re definitely on the right track there!
      2- Depending on how well and with shat material you’ve wrapped, this process still takes a long time. The temp curve will slowly increase slope until it’s running at a rate nearly equal to the initial temperature climb (maybe a little less steep). Bu there are no more slop indicators on the way to doneness.
      3-Remove the wrap at the end of the rest period (see what I wrote above before I read your questions through.)

      Excellent questions! I hope the answers lead to good success for you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.