Steak guide

48 Comments

  1. Thank you for all the info on steaks. No one has ever explained the different cuts to me before.
    I found the info on the different cuts and how to best cook them very helpful.

  2. Chef, thank you for the detailed discussion regarding steak. Although I thought that I was knowledgeable about steak, you provided great insight for me – particularly the grading of beef.

      1. Outstanding detailed description. And the photos were very helpful.
        I’ve never read anything more informative on steaks.

  3. Nice informative article.Being a meatcutter all my life I rarely [no pun] order steak out. Period. Too many variables make up the end product on the plate. Treat yourself. Learn to cook “em, and get to know a couple of nice meatcutters. If you do order out, that’s cool. I know a lot of owner, operator, chefs, and I say support your local people. All my life I’ve miss out on somebody serving me a perfectly done steak with all the trimmings in a nice setting. Why? because I’m big headed. Nobody serves me a steak better than I do. That’s OK, I don’t have the time, ingredients or know how for good Italian, Chinese … But I know some great local places that do. You get the point!

    1. Stanly,
      Thanks for your input! It is true that once you learn how to cook a great steak, eating them at restaurants…well, it’s just not the same! And you’re right that getting to know a meatcutter or a good, local chef is the way to go.
      Happy cooking, and happy eating!

  4. Very informative. I’ve been eating steaks for over fifty years now and it is surprising how little I know about them.Thanks, Clayton

  5. I enjoy all these articles but found this one to be especially valuable. Well written with excellent pictures.

  6. a very informative article! Now I just have to learn the proper methods and estimated times for cooking steaks. I would hate to ruin a good cut of meat or poultry for that matter.

    1. Gary,

      The estimated times will take trial and error for each kind/thickness of steak and each method of cooking. If you want to be able to know about how long it takes, I recommend getting a timer like the TimeStick and timing a few cooks. Write the times in your recipe, and next time you’ll know about how long to plan so you can get dinner on the table when you want it.
      Happy cooking!

  7. Great information, I will try to remember it all and follow the instructions. Thanks for all the help. This should make for a very happy WIFE and that makes for a great life.

  8. What an excellent and informative article which answered questions that I have had forever! Thank you much for putting this out there!

  9. Very informative article. You were particularly kind when you talked about the kooks who prefer their beef well-done! The only puzzling thought I still have is how/why one store’s USDA Choice rib-eye tastes better than another’s. Additionally, when you speak of steak thickness, is there a point at which the steak may be “too thick” for grilling? Finally, regarding your Thermapen: Is the “don’t ever use a fork on a cooking steak” adage in consideration it the Thermapen’s use? How about how/where to insert it into the steak?
    Again, this article is great, and I thank you.

    1. Robert,
      Thank you for reading, and those are great questions.
      First, grading and stores. As I alluded to in the article, grading determines only one aspect of meat quality, running with the assumption that other characteristics will follow from that one measurement. But there are other factors that aren’t recorded in the “choice” labeling. Of instance, breed of cow. Angus is very popular, but it has different characteristics from, say, a Hereford. Not every meat counter will know the breed of cattle.

      Another factor is the slaughter and packing process. While there are standards for cleanliness and wholesomeness that are set and inspected by the government, there are better producers and less good ones. Chances are, you’re getting something akin to what you pay for. Cheap beef may come from cheap cattle or a less-than-quality packing house.

      When it comes to thickness, you really just need to consider the method. A 3″ thick ribeye (aka a small prime rib roast!) can certainly be cooked on the grill, but you will absolutely need to use a two-stage, reverse sear method. Cook it on indirect low heat until it is within about 10°F of your desired pull temp, then move it to sear over hot coals/gas.

      As for sticking a steak with a Thermapen, we’re planning on putting that myth to rest soon with some real science. Suffice it to say that the amount of juice lost by sticking a steak with a Thermapen is less than you’d lose by overcooking the steak! The juice lost from it is minimal.
      But! to minimize the loss, take the temp by going in from the top of the steak, down past the center, and pulling it up through, looking for the lowest temp on the Thermapen. By going in perpendicular to the surface, you create the smallest hole in the meat. Going in from the side creates a long tunnel of moisture loss.

      I hope that all helps, and that you become an expert at steaks!

  10. Great article. Coming from a farm family on both Dad and Mom’s sides it is good to remember your meat selecting, cooking and ordering points. I find that it actually helps in beef, lamb and pork selection.
    There is one more very important point especially in buying beef. That is how long the carcass has been allowed to hang (aging) in the butcher’s cold box before it is processed into different cuts. We always told our local meat locker (butcher) to allow a minimum of 30 days. Usually the longer, the better. Toward 40 was great. When I was young: 1950’s 60’s early 70’s, it would be no problem to ask for this amount of time. Now it is nearly impossible because of butchering expenses and locker space. Grocery stores, unless it is a specialty shop, won’t have these meats on hand. I tend to look for steaks that have been sitting in the display case longer than the others which sometimes give away their time by the color/darkness of the meat. Not always an indicator, but sometimes ……

    1. Brennan,

      Have you considered buying primals or sub-primals and aging them yourself? I know there’s a lively community of DIY beef agers on the internet, and with some ThermoWorks thermometers and hygrometers (humidity meters) you could get that 30 age you like so much!

    2. Meat that has been cut and packaged in plastic wrap doesn’t age; it just gets OLD. It needs air to age and give up some of the moisture. I’ve noticed that some up-scale supermarkets have aging boxes in the meat department. The meat is pricey, but if you can find genuine properly aged beef, it might be worth the splurge.

  11. Excellent treatise on how to buy, cook and enjoy a great steak dinner. The reverse sear is the best way to cook a good steak followed by sous vide.

    1. Jim,
      That is a fine point that needs to be made! Wet aging is aging “in the bag,” where the meat is left in a cryo-vac bag to age. Dry aging is done in a temperature and humidity controlled cooler.
      In wet aging, the goal is tenderization via enzymatic action over time. As the meat sits in its protective bag, the natural enzymes in the meat slowly work to break apart proteins, making the meat more tender and flavorful.
      In dry aging, a lot more happens. Yes, there is the enzymatic action, but there is also evaporation. When the meat loses water, the flavors of the steak are concentrated, which tastes better. Also, there is a literal element of rot in the dry aging process. The outermost pits of the meat actually putrify, but the byproducts of that process are delicious. The flavor process is similar to aging a block of cheese, with bacteria at work to create deeper flavors. But the rot is also the reason a dry-aged steak is so expensive: they cut all the rot off of it before they send it home with you, and that waste (as well as any water lost to evaporation) goes into your price-per-pound.
      I hope that helps!

  12. Thank you SO MUCH for this article!

    I’ve always paid attention to the descriptions of beef sold at the supermarket while examining the marbling, but now I’ll actually have a better idea of what I’m purchasing and why.

    Now, let’s put those Thermapens to work!

  13. The information was simply fantastic. GREAT JOB!! I feel as though I learned a lot from reading it. I will be sure to save it.

  14. I have had good luck with the reverse sear method, but after much trial and error prefer searing the steak first and then either putting it in the smoker at 200 – 225 degrees. I notice little difference in the texture but find it easier to control the final temperature than if I sear it after the low temp smoking.

  15. I’m just totally impressed. Much was known, but MUCH was learned. Thank you for this; I’ll read it several times, I think; and am looking forward to my next steak dinner!

  16. I have heard of folks ordering their steak “blue”. I assume this to be just shy of raw; could you shed some light to this?

    1. Ron,

      Blue is a term for very rare. It’s just past raw. Not my favorite way, but there’s no accounting for taste!

  17. Great article. I’ve read bits and pieces of a lot of what you’ve covered here through the years.
    However, you’ve put it all together for us and I thank you for that.

  18. Well written article (thank you!) and thoughtful comments. I’m guessing a lot of folks didn’t know the difference between a NY and a KC strip. Despite what some say, I’m a bone-in guy . . .

    1. Joel,
      I’m glad you liked it! And hey, if you like the bone in, that’s just great! Happy cooking!

  19. The best investment i have ever made.The mk4 is pricey but well worth the money.I use it for bread, sausage and steaks. Recently bought a second one for my daughter and future son in law. It is a must have for the outdoor griller. I did the reviews before purchasing,but if its good enough for the Americas Test Kitchen it was good enough for me.Keep up the blogs they are very helpful.

  20. I tell my waiter I want my steak taken off the grill at 130*, I then hand him or her my ThermoPop, by the way, be sure to bring it back. lol

  21. The letter grade indicating the age of the animal is not discussed on the USDA / FSIS web-site. Who assigns this letter grade and why?
    If present how does it help in choosing product? I would assume that meat from a younger animal is preferable and this age does not relate to the “dry aging” that some restaurants cite.
    Thanks for all the useful information about beef grades, cuts, and preparation tips (and for my just-purchased ThermoPop).

    1. Quality grading is not mandatory, so some producers forego it. I also can’t find any info on who assigns the score, however. You are correct, though, that the age refers to the animal’s age, not the age of the beef as a cut itself.

  22. This was a very informative article. I order my steaks, ” the rarest you can legally cook it”. At home I never cook my steaks over 117 degrees.

    1. I had never heard of it until you asked! The only reference I can find to it point to it being a sirloin, but I’m not sure of that.

  23. This is a marvelous tutorial on beef. My grandfather was in the wholesale live cattle business when I was a kid (80 years ago). In addition to knowing how to select meat, it’s just as important to know how to properly trim the meat to remove the sinew and silver-skin and other bits and pieces that will never get tender no matter how long they’re cooked. That’s where a good butcher comes into play. Their skill levels are highly variable. Some just mutilate the meat; others enhance it. Befriend your butcher!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.