If you’re looking for a way to make your Thanksgiving dinner more exciting this year, try smoking a turkey! Celebrate the harvest with a turkey that tastes of the great outdoors. With our thermal tips you can be sure that you’ll get a delicious, safe to eat turkey unlike any you’ve served before.
Making a smoked turkey can be daunting because it’s such a large object—a rack of ribs is tiny in comparison—so it is understandable that many people have never tried it out. But in reality, the principles behind smoking a turkey are the same as those behind, say, a pork butt. The main difference is that we want to cook a pork butt to 195°F(91°C) to break down all the connective tissues, but we only want to cook a turkey to a pull temp of 160°F(71°C). Turkey breast is naturally tender and low in connective tissue, and will toughen and dry out if it cooked too high, as we’ve all tasted before. (It is true, however, that the dark meat in the turkey back, thighs, and legs does have connective tissue. For more on this topic, read our post White Meat vs. Dark Meat Turkey Cooking Methods.)
To make sure our smoked turkey comes out juicy, we need to make sure we’re only cooking it to our target pull temperature and not any farther. To do that, we need to make sure we’re placing our thermometer probe correctly. Place the probe in the thickest part of the breast, in the center of the meat. This is the coldest part of the bird, when it reaches our pull temp we know the rest of the bird should be good too.
With all of this in mind, let’s smoke a turkey!
Smoking a Turkey
Compound butter and rubbing the skin
- Prepare a compound butter by softening a stick of butter (using a rolling pin works very well), then mincing herbs—sage, rosemary, and thyme, for instance—and kneading them together with the butter and some ground black pepper.
- Separate the skin of the turkey from each breast with your fingers and hand. Stuff one third of the compound butter under the skin of each breast, smoothing it down under the skin to cover as much meat as possible.
- Melt the remaining herb butter and pour it over the top of the turkey breast. Rub it into the skin with your hands to coat the turkey.
Smoker
- Preheat your smoker to 250°F(121°C) and choose your favorite wood for smoking.
Thermometers
- Place a Pro-Series® High Temp Cooking Probe in the thermal center of the turkey by finding the thickest part of the breast and inserting the probe in its center.
- Clip the Pro-Series® High Temp Air Probe With Grate Clip in your smoker.
- Have a Thermapen® Mk4 or other instant read thermometer at the ready to spot check the turkey at the end of cooking.
Smoking the turkey
- Place the turkey in the smoker and set the alarms on your Smoke™. Set the high-alarm for the meat probe to 160°F(71°C). Set the air probe high alarm to 275°F(135°C) and the low alarm to 225°F(107°C). Close the lid and let it smoke!
Monitor the cooking
- To monitor the progress of your turkey and your smoker temperature without having to stick by the smoker all day, use the Smoke receiver (which uses radio frequency), or try the new Smoke™ Gateway with the free Smoke Gateway app (which you can find in the iTunes or Google Play app stores). The Smoke Gateway connects to your existing Wi-Fi network to enable you to track your temperatures with your smartphone or tablet anywhere you can get a Wi-Fi signal.
Pull temperature
- When your Smoke’s meat probe high alarm sounds at 160°F(71°C), check it with a Thermapen Mk4 in a few places to be sure it is thoroughly cooked. Make sure the lowest temp you see is 160°F(71°C).
- Note: If you see lower temperatures with your Thermapen, either continue smoking and check it again in a little while with your Thermapen OR, using hot mitts, you can reposition your Smoke meat probe until it shows a reading similar to the lowest temperature you’re seeing with your Thermapen and wait for the 160°F(71°C) alarm to sound again.
Rest and enjoy
- Finally, let your turkey rest at least 20 minutes before slicing and enjoying. That rich smokey flavor is amazing with turkey.
With proper monitoring, smoking a turkey for Thanksgiving is no more difficult than making barbecue pulled pork. Treat the family this year. And right now, if you buy a Smoke and Smoke Gateway bundled together, you get a free zippered case to keep them in.
Products Used:
Bruce says
I have been looking for a good yet simple recipe for a turkey on a gas grill and this one seems to be the perfect match for what I am looking for.
I will be looking forward to putting on a Turkey a month from now.
This will save the oven space for the wife to do the pies and muffins and other stuff inside in the oven.
Since I have the Thermoworks Smoke, I will be sitting inside, monitoring the turkey and watching the Vikings beat the Lions while the Turkey is cooking.
Joe D. says
Surprised to see you don’t recommend rubbing the turkey with salt (or brining). Why is that?
Martin says
Joe,
Brining or salting (dry brining) is a great way to make your turkey more tender and moist, and we do recommend salting in some of our other turkey posts. In this case we wanted to focus more on the smoking method than the entire preparation, so we didn’t bring it up. Also we use Butterball turkeys which are pre-injected with a brine, which would make brining redundant for us.
Thanks for the question and I hope this clarifies things. Good luck with your bird!
Rachel says
Hi..great idea this year! As a guide, how long should you plan on to smoke a 20 lb turkey?
Thx so much????
Martin says
Rachel,
Great question! Take a look at the comment we made above to Mike, and good luck smoking your bird!
Mike Verzola says
Any rough estimates for how long the turkey will take to get to temperature, assuming I follow these instructions, and the turkey is approximately 20lbs?
Thanks,
Mike
Martin says
Mike,
Timing a bird that size is very important, so this is a great question. I’d plan on something around 12 hours, and that is according to Butterball’s website: http://www.butterball.com/how-tos/smoke-a-turkey
Just make sure you’re also monitoring the temperature the whole time!
Good luck!
Bob Halcomb says
approximately how long (per pound) does it take to smoke a turkey using your method?
Martin says
Bob,
Figuring out how to time the bird so that the pull temp is reached at the right time for dinner is a real problem. There are factors we can’t control or even take into account with each bird. BUT, as a rough guide, go with about 30 minutes per pound. Definitely factor in some error time on that, but it should point you in the right direction.
Good luck!
Bill Bauer says
You say to set the smoker to 250 deg & pull when the internal meat temp reaches 160 deg. I have done this with turkey & chicken & at that temperature the skin in not edible. Before carving the bird I have to remove all the skin. Others have said that to crisp the after smoking, you need to increase the temp in the smoker, put the bird on a hot grill for a few minutes or in an oven, all set at a high temp around 400 deg. Or you can simply pat the skin dry prior to smoking & smoke the bird at around 325 deg until the 160 temp is reached internally. It takes dry hot heat to make the skin crispy. Any comments about this crispy skin problem? I’m curious.
Martin says
Bill,
You are absolutely correct. The skin right out of the smoker at 250° will be leathery. Moving the bird to a hot oven or grill for 20 minutes or so is a good strategy for crisping the skin, but if you do, be aware that you’re changing the thermal state of the turkey. Lower the temperature you pull the turkey from the smoker by a couple degrees. After the hot-treatment give your bird more time to rest to equalize the temperature gradients. Smoking the turkey at 325° is not very likely to get your skin much crispier than the 250° cook.
Good luck!
Dave says
Can you give me an idea how long a 10 or 12 pound turkey would take using your method? I need an idea of what time to start the cook. Thanks Dave
Martin says
Dave,
There are many variables that go into cooking time, including the starting temp of the bird itself, and going by a clock is not likely to result in a perfect bird. That being said, plan at least 4 hours for the cooking time on a bird that size.
Good luck!
Rick Lear says
I’ve been a home smoker for years and I have smoked pork butt/shoulders, pork ribs, beef briskets, and turkeys. Martin apparently never has because he doesn’t appear to know anything about the correct target internal temperatures for smoking meats.
I guarantee that if you pull a pork butt/shoulder at an IT of 175°F the meat will be inedible. It will be tough with very little of the connective tissue AND fat rendered. I’ve saw this same IT recommended by a poster on a home cooks message board and they were wrong as well. If you’re cooking a pork shoulder with the intention slicing it, perhaps you can get away with a minimum 195°F but there still might be a little toughness to the meat.
The minimum pull IT for a pork butt/shoulder (same cut of meat, different terms) is 199°F. I prefer it to rise to 202°–and the pork meat is never dry, even after resting. Smoking a pork butt/shoulder is really no different from smoking a beef brisket because the same issues apply: both need to be cooked low and slow to an IT of at least 200°F to render all that connective tissue and fat down so the roast comes out juicy and tender.
As for the turkey, the writer displays the same lack of knowledge. Perhaps the writer advises pulling the turkey at an IT of 160°F believing the carryover will raise it to 165°F–which the FDA recommends. I’ve never see than happen although theoretically it is possible.
I do agree with the recommended smoking temp of 250°F is fine. With the high/low air temps, I think setting the high temp alarm at 275°F is too high; 265°F would be sufficient.
One final thought on smoking a turkey: despite what the photo shows of the final turkey result, smoking at a temp of 250°F is not likely to result in browned crispy skin. The skin might be browned but it will most likely be flabby and fatty. What many of us home smokers prefer to do is smoke the turkey until it’s just under the finish IT and then transfer it to a kitchen oven preheated to 450-500°F for about 20-30 minutes (depending on where that IT is) to both fully brown and crisp the skin.
I own one of your thermometers and overall I think your recipe articles are well-written. But in this case, whoever wrote this not only gave out bad information, in the case of the turkey it could be dangerously wrong information.
Martin says
Rick,
Thank you for your careful and thoughtful reply. I’m sorry if you felt the post was inaccurate. I’m anxious to respond directly to your concerns and see if you have any follow up questions. Please see my replies to your three comments below:
1. smoked pork butt to 175°F
You are absolutely correct that pork shoulder should be cooked to 195°F or higher (as we recommend here: http://blog.thermoworks.com/2015/10/pulled-pork-time-temperature-matters/. I meant to suggest that the collagen in the pork shoulder does not BEGIN to break down until the butt reaches 175°F, but I agree that it was misleading and I have corrected the post to read 195°F thanks to your helpful comment.
2. smoked turkey to 160°F
You are also correct about the lack of carryover cooking when smoking a turkey “low and slow.” You should not expect to see much additional rise in temperature after the turkey is pulled from the smoker. 165°F is the USDA-recommended temperature for turkey for an instantaneous 7-log reduction in pathogens. However, the USDA also clearly states that turkey held at 160°F for 16.9 seconds or longer will achieve the same reduction (depending upon the fat content of the turkey). Smoked turkey cooked to 160°F will certainly hold at that temperature for much longer than 17 seconds as the temperature increases so slowly. You can view those USDA turkey “pasteurization” tables here: https://www.fsis.usda.gov/wps/wcm/connect/9ab2e062-7ac8-49b7-aea1-f070048a113a/RTE_Poultry_Tables.pdf?MOD=AJPERES. You can also read more about the pasteurization of poultry in our post here: http://blog.thermoworks.com/2017/04/baked-chicken-breasts-juicy-temperature/
3. skin not crispy at 250°F smoker temperature
Your recommendation to crisp the skin at a higher temperature in the oven is a great idea and one that we frequently recommend. If you were to do that, I would lower the pull temp even a little further to make sure the meat doesn’t dry out in that final stage of cooking.
Thanks for your comments and happy smoking!
Steve says
What temperature would you recommend pulling the Turkey off the smoker if you were to put it in the oven for 20-30 minutes @ 400-450? Never done this way before would like to try it.
Martin says
Steve,
Good question. If you’re planning on crisping it or that long, I’d probably pull it at about 140°-145°. And then pull it from the oven at 157°F. The blast of heat will provide more carryover than the smoker.
Be sure to keep an eye on the temp while it’s in the oven, though! There are some tricky thermodynamics at play when you take the turkey off the heat, move it through cold air and then put in ta higher heat, but that’s the whole point of a good leave-in thermometer isn’t it!
Good luck!