Bread—the staff of life, the very metaphor for food and companionship—is a subject shrouded in tradition, lore, and even legend. Baking bread is one of the most ancient practices of civilized society, and has, therefore, had plenty of time to allow some muddled facts to be folded into its production.
Instructions like “place on warm countertop” or, even worse, “thump bottom of bread to see if it is done” are commonplace in recipes for bread. But how can we cook bread differently now that we live in a technologically advanced civilization, rather than an Iron-age village? Thermometry, of course. And the thermometer you need for bread is a ChefAlarm® leave-in probe thermometer.
To discuss the finer points of thermometry in bread making, we’re going to take a look at lean-dough breads as our example. Lean-dough bread is the most basic kind, often composed only of flour, water, salt, and yeast. While the processes may vary from bread type to bread type within the class, they all share the commonality that they contain no fats (hence the name). Those with butter, oil, or other fats are called ‘rich-dough’ breads.
The thermal principles involved in bread making are essentially the same for rich- and lean-dough breads, with but one notable exception, and as the lean dough is ‘simpler,’ we will use one as the template for our discussion.
Bread Baking Basics
No matter the bread you’re making, there are three major stages: preparation and mixing, bulk fermentation and proofing, and baking. In each phase, there is a critical temperature element that can be accomplished more exactly with modern thermometry than with pre-industrial techniques. Our ancestors did a great job with what they had, but, as Nathan Myhrvold and the Modernist Bread team have shown, we can be more precise, and get more repeatable, exact results by discarding some of the lore and leaning on data. So with that in mind, let’s look at how temperature affects bread baking
- Temperature in preparation/mixing
- Temperature in rising
- Temperature in baking
- Internal temperature for bread
- lean-dough Cuban bread recipe
Temperature and bread, and overview
Temperature in preparation/mixing
Though it may not seem like it, the temperature at which you mix your dough can have a significant effect on the outcome of your bread. The temperature at which your yeast blooms can affect the flavor of your bread. Yeast reactivates best between 110°F and 130°F (43°C and 54°C). But push the activation temp above 140°F (60°C) and you’ll kill the yeast before it can even wake up.
At the same time, if you use water below 105°F (41°C) to wake it up, the yeast will wake up grumpy and you’ll get off-flavors in your bread. You know how bad it is to take a cold shower in the morning when you wanted a hot one, and yeast feels the same!
Then there is flour temperature. Whole grain flours are best stored under refrigeration—or even in the freezer—to prevent rancidification. If you add freezing flour to your dough, it will take a long time to rise. Using room temperature flour eliminates this problem, but if you have cold four, you’re going to want to check its temp before adding it to anything. A great way to bring it to temp is to sift it from a foot or two above the countertop. As the individual grains fall through the sieve, they warm more quickly. Use a Thermapen® to make sure you’re not cold-shocking the yeast out of their comfort zone.
If you want perfect results, you will want to get your dough to an exact starting temp before fermenting/proofing it. Professional bakers, whose livelihoods depend on consistency, actually take into account their mixers’ friction factor when they work out their desired dough temperature (DDT). When kneading dough, the internal friction of the dough creates heat. Each mixer has a heat signature known as the ‘friction factor.’ Professional dough recipes take that number into account and have a final desired dough temp. In fact, there is a formula for the temperature of water to add given certain variables so that your dough comes out at the desired temperature.
To find the water temperature to add to your dough (not just ‘lukewarm water’!), Take the desired dough temp and multiply by 3. Then subtract the room temperature, the flour temperature, and your mixer’s friction factor. Whatever remains is the temperature of water you want to add to your dough.
3 X (DDT) – (room temp + flour temp + friction factor) = water temp*
(That formula works for Fahrenheit scale. See the bottom of the post for a note on Celsius.)
Again, a Thermapen mk4 will give you accurate readings for all of those temperatures, and truly repeatable results. Mind you, this is pretty advanced. Most consumer mixers don’t publish their friction factors, so you have to work the process backwards to find it empirically, and even if you do, most consumer recipes don’t have DDTs anyhow. But if you get serious, you will start using this.
(If you want an easy way to calculate your temperatures, check out the Desired Dough Temp calculator over at The Perfect Loaf. Play around with it, but you can get the equation above by entering ‘3’ for your mulitplication factor and ‘0’ for your preferment.)
Temperature in rising
“Place the dough in a warm spot in your kitchen” is one of my all-time least favorite cooking instructions. Warm in winter or warm in summer? How warm is too warm? Warm enough? Well, it turns out that science has answered that question. According to Harold McGee, the optimal temperature for fermenting and proofing bread dough is 85°F (29°C). Temperatures below that point take longer to ferment, and temperatures higher than that can produce unpleasant flavors in the dough.
Bakers overcome this problem with high-tech proof boxes that use complex algorithms to keep the temperature exactly right. Some home ovens have a ‘proof’ function on them that runs the oven in the neighborhood of 85°–90°F (29°–32°C). If you have one, more power to you.
If you don’t, I recommend the following solution: use an insulated cooler for your proofbox. Coolers will keep heat in just as well as they will keep it out, so you can maintain a relatively constant temperature over the hours needed to ferment your dough. Just measure out a gallon or so of water at 95°F (35°C) using your Thermapen to check the temp, pour it into the cooler, and either put something in the water for your dough bowl to sit on, or just float the bowl in the water. Close the lid, and let your yeast do its job! A ChefAlarm® probe can also be used to monitor the temperature of the proofbox, making sure that the temperature stays in the proper range.
To proof—the name for the final rise after shaping—your bread, try to set up a rack of some kind in the cooler that you can set a pan with the bread on.
Why use water that is warmer than we want our proofer to be? Below is a graph of the temperature in such a cooler proofbox. Into a large cooler chest I put two gallons of 95°F (35°C) water. I put a probe in the water and used an air probe in the air and let the whole thing go overnight with the lid closed. I have included data up until the air temperature dropped below 85°F (29°C), which took about 3 hours. There was immediate heat loss to the walls of the cooler, and the air was never as warm as the water.
Temperature in baking
Once your bread is properly proofed, it’s time to bake. Oven temp is important, and you should follow your specific recipe for it, but most breads are cooked at rather high heat to create leavening steam inside the bread.
Though you needn’t measure the temperature of your bread at every point in the baking, it is an interesting thermal journey to see the ways that temperature affects the bread during baking. And to that end, I present the stages of bread baking:
The thermal stages of baking:
|Gasses are formed and trapped More CO2 from yeast is produced, as are gasses from any chemical leaveners and alcohol vapor from the fermentation
|Starches gelatinize Starch granules swell and burst, creating a thick web of starch molecules
|Proteins coagulate The gluten strands curl up, tightening their links with each other, and solidifying the bread’s structure
|Across the temperature range
|Fats melt In rich doughs, the fats that were emulsified in the dough melt, moistening the dough
|212°F (100°C) (adjusted for elevation)
|Water boils Steam is one of the most important leaveners in bread
|320°F (160°C) and up
|Sugars caramelize, Maillard reaction Sugars on the exterior will brown at this temperature and others will combine with proteins to produce nutty, toasty flavors and beautiful color
|Carryover baking After the bread is removed from the oven, the temperatures will equalize, with the interior continuing to warm as the exterior begins to cool
|Staling (starch retrogradation) Once the bread reaches room temperature, the starch molecules start to shed water and to try to reassemble themselves in to starch granules, a process that makes soft bread feel hard and, well, stale
(On Baking, Pearson, pg . 57)
To what temperature do I cook bread?
Those stages of baking are thermo-centric, but I’ve included them merely for your information—and because I think they’re pretty cool—because you can’t do anything about them. Proteins are going to coagulate at that temperature no matter if you use a thermometer or not. But where a thermometer does matter is for the doneness of your bread.
It has been handed down to us that a bread loaf is done when it produces a “hollow thump” when tapped on the bottom. Humbug. Most people don’t think about it, but there are varying temperatures for bread doneness, just like there are for beef (though an undercooked bun is less likely to cause illness than an undercooked burger). For lean-dough breads the recommended doneness is 190–210°F (88–99°C), while enriched-dough breads are done at 180–190°F (82–88°C) (S. Labensky, et. all, On Baking, 2nd edition, pg. 190). These critical temps are important if you want bread that is cooked through and not gummy in the center but is still moist and tasty.
To achieve these temps, you can spot-check—based on time—with a Thermapen, but a better idea is to monitor the internal temperature much like a roast. We recommend letting the bread cook for about 10 minutes—time enough for the bread to perform its oven-spring and to start setting up a bit—and then inserting a ChefAlarm, with the high-alarm set for your target temperature. The lean dough we’ll be making below was cooked to 200°F (93°C). As noted above, there will be some carryover cooking, so you should set your alarm a few degrees lower than your target temp, depending on the size of loaf.
And speaking of loaf size, it is a great reason to use a ChefAlarm in your baking. Resizing loaves from a recipe will mean a change in cooking time, but it will not mean a change in internal temperature requirements. If you make smaller loaves, use the ChefAlarm to make sure you don’t burn them. If you make a bigger loaf, rest assured it is not doughy in the middle by monitoring that internal temperature!
Lean-dough Cuban Bread Recipe
Florida’s famous Cuban bread is a close cousin of plain French and Italian breads. It is made traditionally with nothing but flour, water, salt, yeast, and a little sugar. Some recipes call for a small amount of fat (often lard) while some leave the fat out altogether, creating a lean dough that is intended for use the day it is baked.
We have based this lean-dough recipe on the Cuban bread recipe from King Arthur Flour, but have omitted the small amount of fat that their recipe calls for, and increased the quantities.
- 25 ½ oz All-purpose flour
- ¾ oz sugar
- 3 tsp salt
- 1+ Tbsp instant or dry active yeast
- 15 ounces water, 110°F (43°C)
- Prepare a proof box by pouring 95°F (35°C) water into a cooler and closing the lid, or use your oven with a proof setting.
- (If using a cooler, monitor the temp with your ChefAlarm, with the low alarm set to 85°F [29°C])
- Add all ingredients to a mixer with a paddle attachment.
- Mix on low speed until well combined.
- Scrape dough from paddle attachment and replace with dough hook.
- Knead for ~5–7 minutes or until a smooth, supple dough is formed.
- Remove the dough from the bowl and grease the bowl with a little butter or oil of your choice.
- Add dough back to the bowl and cover tightly with plastic wrap.
- Place the bowl with the dough in your proof box and let rise for one-half hour.
- Gently fold the dough over on itself to release some of the gas and stretch the gluten.
- Continue to let the dough rise until it has doubled in bulk, about another half hour.
- When the dough has risen enough, turn it out onto a floured surface.
- For loaves like we made, divide the dough in half and form each into a boule by gathering the dough into a seam on the bottom of the ball. You can make other shapes if you like.
- Place them on a baking sheet with either parchment paper or cornmeal on it.
- Cover the loaves and place back in the proofer for yet another hour. Halfway through, preheat the oven to 375°F (191°C).
- Uncover the loaves and spray lightly or brush with water. (If you want them to come out browner, use milk instead of water.)
- Slash the top of each with a sharp knife or razor blade.
- Bake the loaves for 10 minutes.
- Insert a ChefAlarm probe into the very center of the loaf and set the high-temp alarm to 200°F (93°C).
- Bake until the alarm sounds.
- Remove the loaves from the oven and let cool on a rack.
- If you want to thump the bottom of the loaf, do it, but only to make yourself feel happy, not because you have to live by the tyranny of cereal acoustics.
You will find that this bread has a close, tight crumb structure reminiscent of the appearance of store-bought white bread, but with a much more significant mouthfeel, presence, and flavor. Make a Cubano sandwich with it, toast it, or just eat the whole thing right now with butter. That’s what I did. And because you used your ChefAlarm, the texture is going to be perfect. So go make some bread and then break it with someone you care about.
*Desired Dough Temperature formula in Celsius
NOTE! for Celcius measurements, you have to take off a constant to make up for the two scales’ different freezing values. No matter the other factors, Celsius must also subtract 17.8 from the formula for correct outcomes:
3 X (DDT) – (room temp + flour temp + friction factor) – 17.8 = water temp
If you’re interesting baking bread, but want an amazing sandwich loaf instead of a rustic boule, check out our post about classic sandwich bread.
King Arthur Flour, Cuban Sandwich Recipe
Harold McGee, On Food and Cooking
Labensky, Martel, Van Damme, On Baking